Skip to main content

Checking an EU VAT number: simple or qualified confirmation

Checking a VAT number takes seconds — but a "valid" result can mean two different things, and neither one tells you whether a supplier's stock, prices or claims are trustworthy.

Published Last updated

A simple check confirms that a VAT ID is registered and valid on the day you check, for example in the EU VIES service. A qualified confirmation also compares the company's name and address; in Germany the Federal Central Tax Office (BZSt) issues it. Neither says anything about product quality, authenticity or reliability.

What a simple check shows — and what it does not

A simple check answers one question: is this VAT ID registered and valid today in the member state that issued it? The EU's VIES service runs this check by routing your query to the national tax database behind the number. A "valid" result tells you the number exists and is active. It does not tell you who holds it, whether that company trades under the name you expect, or whether the goods it sells are authentic.

In some member states, VIES also returns the registered name and address alongside the valid/invalid result. In others it does not — the result shows "valid" with the name field empty. We checked this directly; see the finding below.

What a qualified confirmation adds, and who issues it

A qualified confirmation goes one step further. Instead of only checking that a number is valid, it compares the name, legal form, city, postcode and street address you provide against the data registered for that number in the other EU country. In Germany, the Federal Central Tax Office (BZSt) is the authority that issues it.

BZSt describes a simple confirmation as telling you "whether a foreign VAT ID is valid, at the time of your enquiry, in the member state that issued it." A qualified confirmation, in BZSt's own wording, additionally checks "whether the company name (including legal form), city, postcode and street address you submit match the data registered in that EU member state's business file."

BZSt also states a fixed order: a simple confirmation must always run before a qualified one. You cannot request the qualified check directly.

What we found when we checked 27 VAT numbers

While researching suppliers for this directory, we ran 27 EU VAT numbers through VIES (26 September 2026). Twenty-two came back valid; three were invalid and two produced no response.

The result split by country was consistent: every one of the 8 valid numbers registered in Germany or Spain (DE 6/6, ES 2/2) came back "valid" with the company name withheld. Every one of the remaining 14 valid numbers — from Italy, Romania, Lithuania, France, the Netherlands and Belgium — returned the full registered legal name directly in the VIES response.

This matches the documented rule that some EU member states, including Germany and Spain, do not share name and address through the standard VIES check for data-protection reasons; the number still shows as valid, just without an identity to go with it. For a buyer, the practical point is the same either way: a "valid, name withheld" result is not a red flag on its own, and a name returned by VIES is not, by itself, proof that the company is the one you are dealing with.

Why a valid VAT ID does not prove reliability, authenticity or quality

A VAT ID check — simple or qualified — answers a tax-registration question. It does not confirm that a supplier ships what it advertises, that its stock is authentic, or that it will honour its terms. Treat it as one input among several checks worth running before a first order, not a stand-alone guarantee.

How long should you keep the confirmation result?

German tax law sets retention periods for business records under § 147 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung), and the period depends on what type of record it counts as. Your tax advisor can confirm the exact retention period that applies to this type of record under German tax law (§ 147 AO). BZSt recommends documenting the result of each confirmation request in one of three equivalent forms: a printout, a saved electronic file, or a screenshot.

A qualified confirmation also carries extra legal weight for German VAT purposes that a simple check does not — it can support the "good faith" protection (Vertrauensschutz) a business relies on when treating an intra-EU delivery as exempt. How that applies to a specific transaction depends on the facts of the case; a tax advisor can confirm how retention and the good-faith rule apply to your business.

Run a simple check yourself with the EU VAT number checker

This is the same first check WholesaleX runs on every listed supplier, described on How we check suppliers

For a broader pre-order checklist, see How to verify a European wholesale supplier

Questions

What is a qualified confirmation?

A qualified confirmation is the second-level check a business can request after a simple VAT ID check. Besides confirming that the number is valid, it compares the company name, legal form, city, postcode and street address you submit against the data registered for that number in the other EU country. In Germany, BZSt issues it; a simple confirmation must always run first.

How long should I keep the result?

Retention periods for German tax records are set out in § 147 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung) and vary by record type. Your tax advisor can confirm the exact period that applies to a VAT confirmation result. BZSt recommends saving the result as a printout, an electronic file, or a screenshot.

Why does a valid VAT ID not prove reliability?

A valid VAT ID, simple or qualified, only confirms that a number is correctly registered — and, for a qualified check, that the registered name and address match. It says nothing about whether a supplier ships authentic goods, honours its stated terms, or is reliable to deal with. Those questions need separate checks, such as the ones in our wholesaler checklist.

General information, not legal or tax advice.

Sources

  1. BZSt — Bestätigung von USt-IdNrn. (FAQ), German Federal Central Tax Office
  2. VIES — VAT Information Exchange System, European Commission